TL;DR

When a page is close to page one, create a focused guide for the exact query and link the guide to the page already ranking. The guide gives the search a next step, while the ranking page gives it a path in.

what should i do when a page is close to page one?

Create a focused guide for the exact query. Give that search a clear next step instead of publishing another broad page.

Then link the guide to the page that is already ranking. The existing page gives the guide a path in.

why connect the guide to a page that's already ranking?

The guide serves the exact search, and the page already ranking connects readers to it. Each page has a clear role in that path.

It is a simple pattern to repeat, and easy to miss when you are busy publishing more pages.

FAQ
How do I support a page that is close to page one?

Make a focused guide for the exact query. Link that guide to the page that is already ranking.

Should I create a guide for an exact search query?

A focused guide gives that search a clear next step. Connect it to a page that is already ranking.